diff --git a/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/features/notifications/components/column_settings.js b/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/features/notifications/components/column_settings.js
index 067696332..c01a21e3b 100644
--- a/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/features/notifications/components/column_settings.js
+++ b/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/features/notifications/components/column_settings.js
@@ -5,6 +5,7 @@ import { FormattedMessage } from 'react-intl';
 import ClearColumnButton from './clear_column_button';
 import GrantPermissionButton from './grant_permission_button';
 import SettingToggle from './setting_toggle';
+import PillBarButton from './pill_bar_button';
 
 export default class ColumnSettings extends React.PureComponent {
 
@@ -34,7 +35,6 @@ export default class ColumnSettings extends React.PureComponent {
 
     const showPushSettings = pushSettings.get('browserSupport') && pushSettings.get('isSubscribed');
     const pushStr = showPushSettings && <FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.push' defaultMessage='Push notifications' />;
-    const pushMeta = showPushSettings && <FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.push_meta' defaultMessage='This device' />;
 
     return (
       <div>
@@ -80,77 +80,77 @@ export default class ColumnSettings extends React.PureComponent {
         <div role='group' aria-labelledby='notifications-follow'>
           <span id='notifications-follow' className='column-settings__section'><FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.follow' defaultMessage='New followers:' /></span>
 
-          <div className='column-settings__row'>
-            <SettingToggle disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'follow']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
-            {showPushSettings && <SettingToggle prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'follow']} meta={pushMeta} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'follow']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'follow']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
+          <div className='column-settings__pillbar'>
+            <PillBarButton disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'follow']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
+            {showPushSettings && <PillBarButton prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'follow']} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'follow']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'follow']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
           </div>
         </div>
 
         <div role='group' aria-labelledby='notifications-follow-request'>
           <span id='notifications-follow-request' className='column-settings__section'><FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.follow_request' defaultMessage='New follow requests:' /></span>
 
-          <div className='column-settings__row'>
-            <SettingToggle disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'follow_request']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
-            {showPushSettings && <SettingToggle prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'follow_request']} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'follow_request']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'follow_request']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
+          <div className='column-settings__pillbar'>
+            <PillBarButton disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'follow_request']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
+            {showPushSettings && <PillBarButton prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'follow_request']} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'follow_request']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'follow_request']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
           </div>
         </div>
 
         <div role='group' aria-labelledby='notifications-favourite'>
           <span id='notifications-favourite' className='column-settings__section'><FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.favourite' defaultMessage='Favourites:' /></span>
 
-          <div className='column-settings__row'>
-            <SettingToggle disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'favourite']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
-            {showPushSettings && <SettingToggle prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'favourite']} meta={pushMeta} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'favourite']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'favourite']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
+          <div className='column-settings__pillbar'>
+            <PillBarButton disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'favourite']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
+            {showPushSettings && <PillBarButton prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'favourite']} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'favourite']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'favourite']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
           </div>
         </div>
 
         <div role='group' aria-labelledby='notifications-mention'>
           <span id='notifications-mention' className='column-settings__section'><FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.mention' defaultMessage='Mentions:' /></span>
 
-          <div className='column-settings__row'>
-            <SettingToggle disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'mention']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
-            {showPushSettings && <SettingToggle prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'mention']} meta={pushMeta} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'mention']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'mention']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
+          <div className='column-settings__pillbar'>
+            <PillBarButton disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'mention']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
+            {showPushSettings && <PillBarButton prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'mention']} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'mention']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'mention']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
           </div>
         </div>
 
         <div role='group' aria-labelledby='notifications-reblog'>
           <span id='notifications-reblog' className='column-settings__section'><FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.reblog' defaultMessage='Boosts:' /></span>
 
-          <div className='column-settings__row'>
-            <SettingToggle disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'reblog']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
-            {showPushSettings && <SettingToggle prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'reblog']} meta={pushMeta} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'reblog']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'reblog']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
+          <div className='column-settings__pillbar'>
+            <PillBarButton disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'reblog']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
+            {showPushSettings && <PillBarButton prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'reblog']} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'reblog']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'reblog']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
           </div>
         </div>
 
         <div role='group' aria-labelledby='notifications-poll'>
           <span id='notifications-poll' className='column-settings__section'><FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.poll' defaultMessage='Poll results:' /></span>
 
-          <div className='column-settings__row'>
-            <SettingToggle disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'poll']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
-            {showPushSettings && <SettingToggle prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'poll']} meta={pushMeta} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'poll']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'poll']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
+          <div className='column-settings__pillbar'>
+            <PillBarButton disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'poll']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
+            {showPushSettings && <PillBarButton prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'poll']} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'poll']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'poll']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
           </div>
         </div>
 
         <div role='group' aria-labelledby='notifications-status'>
           <span id='notifications-status' className='column-settings__section'><FormattedMessage id='notifications.column_settings.status' defaultMessage='New toots:' /></span>
 
-          <div className='column-settings__row'>
-            <SettingToggle disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'status']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
-            {showPushSettings && <SettingToggle prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'status']} meta={pushMeta} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'status']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
-            <SettingToggle prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'status']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
+          <div className='column-settings__pillbar'>
+            <PillBarButton disabled={browserPermission === 'denied'} prefix='notifications_desktop' settings={settings} settingPath={['alerts', 'status']} onChange={onChange} label={alertStr} />
+            {showPushSettings && <PillBarButton prefix='notifications_push' settings={pushSettings} settingPath={['alerts', 'status']} onChange={this.onPushChange} label={pushStr} />}
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['shows', 'status']} onChange={onChange} label={showStr} />
+            <PillBarButton prefix='notifications' settings={settings} settingPath={['sounds', 'status']} onChange={onChange} label={soundStr} />
           </div>
         </div>
       </div>
diff --git a/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/features/notifications/components/pill_bar_button.js b/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/features/notifications/components/pill_bar_button.js
new file mode 100644
index 000000000..223b7f75f
--- /dev/null
+++ b/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/features/notifications/components/pill_bar_button.js
@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
+import React from 'react';
+import PropTypes from 'prop-types';
+import ImmutablePropTypes from 'react-immutable-proptypes';
+import classNames from 'classnames'
+
+export default class PillBarButton extends React.PureComponent {
+
+  static propTypes = {
+    prefix: PropTypes.string,
+    settings: ImmutablePropTypes.map.isRequired,
+    settingPath: PropTypes.array.isRequired,
+    label: PropTypes.node.isRequired,
+    onChange: PropTypes.func.isRequired,
+    disabled: PropTypes.bool,
+  }
+
+  onChange = () => {
+    const { settings, settingPath } = this.props;
+    this.props.onChange(settingPath, !settings.getIn(settingPath));
+  }
+
+  render () {
+    const { prefix, settings, settingPath, label, disabled } = this.props;
+    const id = ['setting-pillbar-button', prefix, ...settingPath].filter(Boolean).join('-');
+    const active = settings.getIn(settingPath);
+
+    return (
+      <button
+        key={id}
+        id={id}
+        className={classNames('pillbar-button', { active })}
+        disabled={disabled}
+        onClick={this.onChange}
+        aria-pressed={active}
+      >
+        {label}
+      </button>
+    );
+  }
+
+}
diff --git a/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/styles/components/columns.scss b/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/styles/components/columns.scss
index 90aa5859d..aaf2c9572 100644
--- a/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/styles/components/columns.scss
+++ b/app/javascript/flavours/glitch/styles/components/columns.scss
@@ -483,6 +483,50 @@
   margin-right: 5px;
 }
 
+.column-settings__pillbar {
+  display: flex;
+  overflow: hidden;
+  background-color: transparent;
+  border: 0;
+  border-radius: 4px;
+  margin-bottom: 10px;
+  align-items: stretch;
+}
+
+.pillbar-button {
+  border: 0;
+  color: #fafafa;
+  padding: 2px;
+  margin: 0;
+  margin-left: 2px;
+  font-size: inherit;
+  flex: auto;
+  background-color: $ui-base-color;
+  transition: background-color 0.2s ease;
+
+  &[disabled] {
+    cursor: not-allowed;
+    opacity: 0.5;
+  }
+
+  &:hover:not([disabled]) {
+    background-color: darken($ui-base-color, 10%);
+  }
+
+  &.active {
+    background-color: $ui-highlight-color;
+  }
+
+  &.active:hover:not([disabled]) {
+    background-color: lighten($ui-highlight-color, 10%);
+  }
+
+  /* TODO: check RTL? */
+  &:first-child {
+    margin-left: 0;
+  }
+}
+
 .empty-column-indicator,
 .error-column,
 .follow_requests-unlocked_explanation {